Back to the corpus

Health and measurement · Essay

Younger, according to what?

Could your health age get younger while your memory gets worse?

Anil R. Wadhwani, MD, PhDSeptember 20, 20266 minute read

Imagine that someone living with dementia wears a WHOOP. Their sleep and activity improve enough to produce a younger age score. Meanwhile, their family notices that they need more help getting through the day.

A reassuring number can carry more meaning than it measures.

What would the family make of that number?

I can imagine wanting to believe it. When someone you love has dementia, a sign that something is going well is not a small thing.

Then I am the doctor explaining why it may not mean what they hoped. That is a miserable role to inherit from a consumer product.

A resting heart rate sounds like a measurement of something specific. Being told you are younger sounds like a much larger piece of news.

A company might never explicitly promise that larger meaning. It still has some responsibility for finding out whether people hear it. If reassurance forms on the screen and the qualification arrives in the examining room, the clinician gets to deliver the disappointment.

A health score is only as broad as what it measures.

WHOOP’s published inputs include sleep, activity, fitness, and body composition. They do not include a direct assessment of memory or thinking. The company describes Healthspan as a wellness feature, not a medical device.

Better sleep and fitness would be welcome. I would want to celebrate that progress. But the number has not assessed the person’s memory, judgment, or ability to manage daily life.

The family could have good news about some things and worsening concerns about others. A single age makes that harder to see.

The screen should make room for both truths.

Devices people already wear might eventually help us follow meaningful changes between visits. AirPods, for example, raise interesting research questions about speech, listening, and brief repeated tasks. They do not currently provide a validated way to track mild cognitive impairment.

Any useful measure would have to distinguish a change in cognition from hearing difficulty, distraction, or a noisy room. It would have to show what changed, what did not, and how much uncertainty remained.

That same standard should apply to a health-age score. If memory was not assessed, that should be easy to understand while looking at the result. The person should not discover the omission only after the number has become a source of hope.

Then I can be glad their fitness is improving, ask about the changes their family is noticing, and take both seriously. I would rather spend our time on those questions than begin by taking apart a piece of good news.

What the current products say.

New essays when they are ready.